
As if the news that your partner doesn’t want to be with you any longer isn’t enough, they often think they have to try to comfort you – to make you feel better.
What most of the “Dumpers” simply do not understand is: they CANNOT give any comfort. They are only able to give as much comfort as a drug would to a drug addict.
But I don’t blame them.
I’ve been both, “Dumpee” and “Dumper”. The truth is when you care, none of these roles is a walk in the park.
There are certain rules you can follow to break up gracefully, yes, but most of the “Dumpers” have never heard of this.
The result is – they say stupid things that make you hate them, and prolong your healing time.
I’ve listed below 10 of the worst phrases dumpers have thrown at my readers, as reported in the emails I receive. Hopefully YOU will not make the same mistakes in the future.
This is an all-time classic.
There are actually three things behind this:
The no-contact rule demands that there is no friendship after a break up, and this is proven to be the best way to go.
Period.
This is something completely stupid to say.
When you are looking for an answer, an explanation, then this answer will confuse you completely.
This sentence is also a big no-no.
Although I admit that there can be situations where the Dumper honestly thinks that they still love the person with whom they are breaking up with, but it is NOT ok to say it.
I understand that the dumper might think that it’s easier for the one left behind, but trust me, it isn’t. On the contrary, it is MUCH harder to hear that your Ex still loves you.
“Then why is he breaking up with me?” This is a legitimate question, which the Dumper never could answer in a way that the Dumpee understands it.
There are some more stupid phrases in the same category:
These are all terrible statements you really don’t want to hear from your Ex who’s breaking up with you.
This is sort of a classic one.
People have written me that they’ve heard this one after several years of being together. With this background, such a sentence is only a slap in the face, and an insult.
This is usually followed by, “You deserve better than me”.
This one, while also meant to give comfort, accomplishes the opposite.
The next thing you are going to hear after this is usually, “We should take a time-out”.
This happens a lot and is almost always a sign of cowardice: The dumper had the plan to break up, but pulled the plug. Instead they are postponing the problem, on the cost of the one left behind. The following “time-out” will be hell for them: they don’t know whether they have been dumped or not. The uncertainty is just unbearable.
In this case, I recommend for you to reply: “I don’t want a time-out. You have to decide right away whether you want to continue the relationship or not!”
Yes, life means making experiences, the good and the ugly – but I don’t need YOU to tell me this during the break up, dear Dumper!
I’m sure you don’t want to hurt the one you’re breaking up with, but I’ve got news for you: You ALWAYS do.
It’s impossible to break up with someone without hurting. That’s a fact. All you can do is follow some rules and try to make it as graceful as possible.
This is of course difficult, but doable.
Now what’s that supposed to mean? Is this a hidden clue that it might later come to reconciliation?
While this is very often just an expression the Dumper throws in without thinking about it, the Dumpee will not forget it. In fact, this sole expression will most likely lead to harmful “overthinking”.
This is very often an attempt to draw attention to themselves, hoping to distract from the horrible situation that is happening. If it’s followed by something like, “my life is a mess”, then the Dumper is trying to be pitiful.
They don’t know what they want, but they still want to break up.
Don’t play this game.
If you are the Dumper, then please avoid sentences like this. I’m sure they are said with the best intentions, but they can only do harm to the person left behind.
Plan ahead what you are going to say, be clear in your intention and leave no doubt. This is the best you can do.
If you are the Dumpee and your Ex throws sentences like this at you, try to not take them to heart. Ignore them the best you can.
All the information you need is that your partner wants to break up with you, as painful as that might be.
The best you can do is to forget everything they say while breaking up, how they say it is not relevant. The consequences of it are hard enough to deal with – don’t burden yourself with the details.
Now it’s your turn: What have you heard from your Ex that you really hated? Please list those phrases in the comment section.
Your friend,
Eddie Corbano
Eddie Corbano is a breakup-coach, relationship-advisor and founder of LovesAGame. He suffered from a devastating break up in 1998. Since then, he dedicated his life to helping others getting the best of this existential experience. The overcoming of a break up is an important step to autonomy and independency. Eddie Corbano developed some new coaching programs, which focus on evolving inner strength and the power to set and reach any personal goal. (Article written on April 24th, 2009)
Show all posts by Eddie Corbano
Join my Free E-Mail-Newsletter "The Secrets of Ultrafast Breakup Recovery" and you will learn:
Please enter your Name and Email:
Recently I had what I consider to be the worst break up I’ve had. Not that the guy acted like a jerk or was wishy washy, but 90% of the talk was about how I failed him, what I didn’t do, his frustration and my muffled response to his grief. Later on I realized he didn’t reflect on how he contributed to the rupture – if he did, he wouldn’t acknowledge it, wouldn’t acknowledge what positives I brought to the relationship too. “Why didn’t you do that? It’s too late now” kind of remarks. I haven’t called him up to ‘unload’ of course, but feeling bottled up is making it hard for me to move on.
1,2,3,6,8
I’ve heard all of the bullets in number three.
When my ex broke up with me almost two weeks ago, a few days later, I got the news that my ex is in a new relationship.
Oh, that hurts until now. And all those numbers I mentioned were all said when my ex gave me the breakup call. My ex did admit that he has feelings for me still but broke up with me because he did not feel that it was right to be in that relationship. Now, ex has a new other half.
What sucks is that my ex is my best friend also.
@Co –
I just experienced the same type of break up and it is literally killing me, I was so devoted to my boyfriend that no one else in my life existed, only to realize that he was controlling every aspect of my life, how to talk, how to walk, who to be friends with etc…stupid me put up with it for 3 years….when I finally couldnt take it any more I tried talking to him which resulted in him degrading me with every name in the book and threatining me with violence, Why am I still feeling so much pain when I should be happy to be free…
maybe you are like me, when you meet someone they are stunned by how amazing you are. You are so confident, sexy funny etc…then you fall in love and damn, you loose yourself in that person. I have lost the two most special people in my life, one just days ago because of this. I seem strong and confident and when im single I am, but when someone tells me they love me and i love them, then i loose myself and become mush and in turn can be treated badly.My heart is so wide open and broken right now as i broke my own rules as i believed someone when they said they loved me and wanted me. the trouble is ME in a relationship isnt ME out of one. God, please help me get this right! Im lonely!!!
@Co – just get it out here believe me, its better than sending him the e mail!!! i recently read hes just not that into you and knew i should have dumped him and i did! but i was so in awe of him that i let him back in. things were amazing and i made every commitment possible to move and be in the same city as him, 3 days before i move, he dumps me! i feel so betrayed and used and sad and lonely and i obviously still love him as love sadly doesnt switch off when you get dumped. the thought of being with someone else makes me want to be sick, but i know one day i will be ready, unfortunately time will help. All i know is this, never give up your friends job security for a man, cos if it goes wrong you are lost hurt angry and helpless.
@seasea – so true! i have just been dumped by a married man who promised me and gave me a wonderful time, but now i am left with just painful memories of how good it was, while he lives his life for another 6 months until some other gullible girl comes along and listens to the BS and relieves his boredom for a while. please it will hurt for you to walk away, but if lhe oves you he will leave her and find you, i thought mine would…. now i am left with a bottle of wine a pack of cigarettes and very sad!!! Dont waste the pretty darling x
@rossana – i love everything you have written but please get this right! Dont loose yourself or your friends for someone you love! Your loved one should compliment these things. I am 35 and am still trying to learn this lesson sweetheart. But yes long distance relationships do work and can be very exciting with all this new technology, just remember you and your friends are real time. good luck x
@shelley – watch it with him, you are way more exciting believe me!
@Kayla I agree! just got burned that way myself….. next!!! btw you have done nothing wrong if he really wanted you and was emotionally available, hed be with you darling. meet a man you can have your own baby with xxx
@Mandy – can you move there ?
Dino, I am like that also. Guys I meet can’t believe how lucky they are to be with me. Their families are so happy their son has found this hidden “gem”. They marvel at how beautiful, confident, ect. I am but I then jump in and give all my love. I love with all my heart, too much. I give up everything and concentrate only on them. At first I think they’re flattered and i take that to mean they like it but then later it becomes too much. How do I stop those feelings? I don’t know, I”ve not figured that out yet. How do I love just a little and not too much?
I can only wish that i was spared my feelings. My ex has broken up with me about 10 times and always comes back! even when he says he never wants me again.. and for some reason i always let him come back to me… i am convinced that it is over this time but He did say he would always love me probably b/c i forced it out of him and that we were each other’s first loves but that statement just makes absoloutly no sense to me. if you love someone then why the heck dont you wanna be with them…
I was dumped a few weeks ago and got about 3 or 4 of those sentences. Most hurtful was “I love you, but I’m not sure I am in love with you anymore”. Plus, good ol’ “I have always been afraid of commitment”… after being together for 4 years and living together for 2. I am taking it day by day, but I wish I knew the real reasons for the breakup. Those blanket statements are completely damaging. They mean nothing and leave you over-analyzing every possible reason the relationship ended. Right now, I am blaming it all on myself since I wasn’t given a honest “dismissal”. Painful.
@Michele –
You might never know why you were dumped. These statements from the dumper never really helps the dumpee. It will hurt, BUT, don’t blame yourself. It is the worst thing you can do. I’ve been through it. My ex said most if not all of the statements above. No matter what he/she say, it will NEVER be good enough to bring comfort. Just make sure to take care of yourself.
Trust me…
Thank you Kelvin. This guy was truly “The One” for me and it feels as though all of this came out of the blue. Its hard to not blame myself; why else could he have wanted to go? I know that it could be for a multitude of reasons, some of which might have nothing to do with me. Doesn’t make this any easier.
Trying to keep my head up and treat myself right.
@Michele –
…get it straight into your head because it is really difficult to put it there (at least for me it was) …there is plenty of fish in the sea, and as long as you grow up and get in control of your infantile imagination and feelings without becoming a cold paranoiac frigid chick maaaany of those fishes will taste better trust me;)
Of course it was your fault…you crashed on the wrong “The One”, simple as that, nothing more nothing less, no multitude of reasons, actually there is no “individual reason” but a simple “state of things” that has evolved in this manner. You cannot fix anything and you definitely cannot learn anything struggling to analyze each moment of your relationship to find out what you should have done, remember no two relationships are the same. You suffer now because you kept fooling yourself with that “The One” “Mister Big” – whatever story and failed to see the signs and take action in a period in which you would had suffered less
@Michele –
You will be fine. Just stop overthinking. It will just make yourself miserable. Been there, done that. I am still working on it. Personally, stop blaming yourself.
Like Sergio says, there are many fishes in the ocean.
Don’t put “The One” on a pedestal…
Cuz it will crash and hurt like crap…
@Sergio -
I don’t think I will ever turn into a cold, paranoid person over this. I have a good sense of self and I know that I am capable of giving all of my love to someone. I think that I am still in shock and without closure, so I am searching for reasons to fill my head. I know its not the right move, but that doesn’t make it easy to stop. I am trying my best, but its the phase I am in trying to deal with this.
Thank you for your advice. I can’t go back and change anything. Maybe we weren’t meant to be together, but I don’t believe that in the slightest at this point; one day I will realize it.
I was myself and I gave my all and I have to feel good about that and move forward.
The same thing happened to me actually almost on the same day (aug 30th). He was controlling but WOW I loved him so whatever he said to do, wear, talk to I did. He became emotionally AND physically abusive and we arent kids..we are 40 and 42. He broke up with me then had sex w me one more time and 3 days later was dating someone else who thought we had been broken up for months.
Hindsight.: the man is and always WILL BE a liar, Since then I have found out basically EVERYTHING he ever told me about himself, his life etc were lies. He, I believe, has a personality disorder and DEF. has a drinking and cocaine abuse habit. I am SO better off without him in my life. However..part of me wants to still be with him. guess that’s my codependent side.
Anyway it gts better. It never gts easier. I don’t cry daily anymore but Iget choked up sometimes. When I see how DUMB his new GF is (she knows what he is..I told her..Oh and also, he cheated on her two different times w me and I did tell her that) it makes me feel better…he is HER problem now..she still goes back even though she says she believes me. She had been dating him for 5 weeks and he was telling her he loved her…then coming home and sleeping with me…and the other half of Nashville. He’s disgusting. He is also broke and is trying to latch onto her money. She has no clue..thinks he is loaded. If she only believed the truth…a rolex and a mercedes and a porsche do NOT make a man a rich man when they can’t even pay the bills. and has like 0 credit. and a credit rating of 200.
Anyway I had no closure either. He broke u with me via text..lol I had to go thru a lot of pain. I went back to church and that helped me to know he was God’s problem..not mine. I see him out drunk and I do try to tell myself he is doing to her what he did to me now….and it makes it better. I am friends with BOTH his ex wives and they are SO supportive..they had it allll happen to them to. It has been about 2.5 months now and I still think about him daily..but it did get better. I have met a WONDERFUL, kind and very generous man who treats me lik a queen. I don;t want the crap I put up with for 18 months anymore.
Moral of the story is a leopard never changes his spots. PERIOD. There are WAY too many good men out there to be conned by a piece of crap. Do NOT become bitter…just ackowledge the red flags..don’t think they arepretty flowers swaying in the breeze…
it is unfortunate but you will never know the real reasons. My ex waited until we had been broken up for 2 months and then had sex again to tel me he had fallen out of love with me months before we broke up…..and ten when I left he called me and said “I want you to know i’d try again with you if our family and friends did not know all that happened” (ie: he cheated on me and was a drug user/alchoholic/ and physically abusive). WHY would someone say that?? You’re telling me you’d want to work it out BUT you just said you wre NOT in love with me? PHYSCO. Thats why.
NEVER been said better…so true. You will NEVER know but really…who cares? he’s done..he’s moved on…you can do the same. And remember..the BEST revenge i a GOOD LIFE!!!! Find yourself someone who will treat you like a princess and our ex will (TRUST ME) be soooo jealous! lol NOT tha we do this so they want us ack…we do it because we want them to feel as bad as they made us feel.
MAybe you are a little relationhsip addicted? I think I was for certain. I felt the same way about my ex BF…very addicted. He ws like a drug to me.
@D –
I don’t think I”m a relatsionship addict. I mean, I knew the man had faults but I was willing to overlook them and still make a life with him. I think what got him was frist off, he was just divorced in March, I started going out with him in June and he had a relationship before me (after his divorce). I think he was jumping into relationships too soon. But the downfall of the relationship started one night when I told him all my good qualities and named things I had going for me and ask him what he had to add to my life. (We had this conversation because anytime he’d get mad he would say “he was never getting married again”. Anyway, I don’t even know why I”m upset over the breakup but I am.
My ex dumped me recently and used his family and financial issues as the “problem”. He also said “I will always love you, maybe someday we can smile about this”. I just think this is a cowardly move, I think the Dumper needs to be honest…it will hurt the Dumpee but atleast it’s not giving hope to them.
its been about three months since my breakup.. and im STILL not over it, it basically sucks cause im litterally stuck in a life i hate.. im a junior in highschool and he went off to college, i just keep thinking about everyhing he promised me that i was the only girl he wanted to be with and all the stuff like that and how him going to college he wanted to make it work. he was my first real relationship, but he was really clingy so i lost most of my friends because of it.. i thought itd be okay and i want to get better im just struggling.. i really just want to go to college somewhere far away so i can just forget about everything..cause now he doesnt even give me the time of day. life sucks. i still love him but i know i shouldnt. what should i do im just miserable from every aspect possible.