Break Up and Divorce 5 Reasons Why People Fall Out Of Love

5 Reasons Why People Fall Out Of Love

Photo by Babet Hendrix

“How do you know when it’s over?“
” Maybe when you feel more in love with your memories than with the person standing in front of you.” ”• Gunnar Ardelius

I recently watched a movie where the main character kept asking people, “If two people love each other, but they just can’t seem to get it together, when do you get to that point of enough is enough?”.

The movie implies that the right answer to this question is “never,” and if you are romantically inclined – as I certainly am – you are tempted to agree.

But unfortunately, life doesn’t work that way.

I’ve learned the hard way, and I suppose that most of you out there have too, that not being able to get it together for a long, ongoing period of time is just a waste of the same.

If you try for years, and you never see your relationship as “fulfilled”, then the point of “enough is enough” is reached.

You don't want anything else than the ‘real’ experience of “Authentic Love.”

Because love alone is not enough.

It has to be the true love called “Authentic Love,” and the love must be celebrated.

If you can’t seem to get it together, then something is wrong.

Still thinking about your Ex? Click here to take the test to learn how long it takes to heal... and how you can speed up the process.

Not getting it together for a long time becomes “Toxic Love,” and you want to stay away from this one.

When this “in limbo” kind of relationship state happens, it would seem to me that there is something wrong with the “love” you feel.

It seems more likely to me that one of you has fallen out of love, and what still binds you together is habit and the mere idea of being together.

That raises the question:

How do people fall out of love?

What happens to someone who was “all in”, to suddenly start making a 180-degree turn and proclaiming, “I don’t love you anymore”?

Isn’t real love supposed to last forever?

I am sure that most of you who are currently going through a painful break-up have asked yourselves this exact question.

“How can my boyfriend/girlfriend/husband/wife stop loving me, just like that?”

To answer questions like these, some time ago I wrote about why people fall out love, and I want to expand a little on that because this concept is so difficult to grasp.

“How can my boyfriend stop loving me, just like that?”

Firstly, these kinds of things happen.

Unfortunately, many people can fall out of love and start to move on long before the actual break-up happens.

Secondly, it the necessity of significance doesn’t happen over night.

It’s a process that needs time.

People who were just confronted with this terrible finality of a breakup cannot understand how a once so loving partner can suddenly turn into this so different, and often even cold, and strange person.

But we have to understand that whatever made them lose their love feeling, happened gradually over the period of weeks or months.

Maybe they struggled against falling out of love, maybe they even fought for keeping it.

They may have talked to us, raised their concerns, (hopefully), and there must have been red flags that we missed.

Let’s ignore the cheaters, abusers, narcissists and sociopaths at the moment, (who weren’t really in love in the first place).

Let’s just look at the normal “dumpers,” (forgive the word).

Whether they fought for the relationship or not, at some point, they fell out of love, but stayed in the relationship anyway, (because of loyalty, habit, appearance, fear…).

When they finally initiate the break-up, they are well over it in their recovery, and have moved on in their head already – they are months ahead of us.

That explains why they can immediately jump into a new relationship, and many of them do.

Often they even use a new relationship as a catalyst to leave.

It’s unfair, isn’t it? And beyond all pain.

Those of us who were left behind, have to deal with the fact that they were not only gone but also that someone else took OUR place in their heart.

If your Ex is still single, then consider yourself lucky.

For the rest of us, accepting this fact, and starting the recovery, is a MUST.

So what are the five main reasons people in a relationship fall out of love? And more importantly, is there something I can do to prevent it?

Here they are:
The 5 Main Reasons Why People Fall Out of Love.

1. They Weren’t In Love In The First Place

It’s not really possible to fall out of love if you never WERE in love, right? The reason why they do, nevertheless, is because they confuse being in love with something else.

This often happens when people look for a relationship to substitute a need.

For instance, the need to not be alone, or the need for significance.

Men often use women to replace their lack of self-esteem or use them as a status symbol.

Whatever it might be, it happens a lot, and it’s confused with “real love.”

2. A Seemingly “Compatibility” Became “Incompatibility”

As you may well know, at the beginning of a relationship we see the world, (and our new partner), through rose-colored glasses.

Everything is wonderful.

We have so much fun, and we are such a match … haven’t even had a single fight … yet.

Until the love-drug subsides, and slowly but certainly, we are kicked back into reality.

Suddenly there is friction. Suddenly there are differences. Suddenly there are terrible fights.

Where has the compatibility gone?

The answer to that is that it often was never there, to begin with.

Often we are not who we really are.

Both of you have given your best to be the ideal version of yourselves, even if that meant becoming someone else.

We are so desperately trying to please the new partner. We want them to be a perfect match at all cost.

So we are not who we really are.

This is where we can do better in the next relationship – to always stay ourselves!

And if the new partner doesn’t like who we are?

Then toss them. He or she wasn’t a fit anyway.

You don’t want an artificial relationship that explodes after the expiration date.

You want the real thing, with a real you, as part of it.

3. There’s Too Much Boredom And Routine

If you don’t water your plant every day, it will die. As simple as that.

As will your love and relationship if you don’t maintain it on a regular basis.

Love in a romantic relationship is not an abstract thing that exists and stands by itself.

It has to be fostered and taken care of on a daily basis.

Move away from that “Disney fairy tales, happily ever after” love-concept that’s been indoctrinated into you from early on.

The prince and princess don't necessarily stay together their whole life … there is drama, there is cheating, there is divorce in the real world today.

A thriving relationship is work. And only work will make it grow.

This can be done by daily love rituals, weekly communications sessions, (instead of watching TV), creating “memory-beacons,” regular live affection, and sharing mutual interests and hobbies.

Love... you have to take care of it before it will take care of you. Click to Tweet

4. The Relationship Didn’t Go In The Desired Direction For Both

This is not quite similar to being incompatible, this is what people call “growing apart” .

When you started the relationship, you had more or less the same goals, shared world-views and expectations on how to grow the relationship, and thoughts about how to make the next logical step together.

While this may have been mutually honest, priorities can change.

Maybe at the beginning, you both agreed to get married in the near future, with kids and the whole package.

And maybe it sounded great at that time, but then for one of you, the priority changed to, for example, getting that promotion at work.

Or one partner got a new job with new colleagues, new challenges, and goals, while the other one wasn’t able to adapt to the new situation.

Things like this will create problems and friction in the relationship.

Unfortunate as it is – this is no one's fault – but it can cause people to fall out of love.

5. The Love Became Toxic

The rose-colored glasses came off not so long ago, and all of a sudden behaviors come to light that was unexpected and very unpleasant.

For example, people can become obsessed with the relationship and act needy, demanding and clingy.

Or they become control freaks – they use “emotional blackmail” , and very often become verbally aggressive, (sometimes even physically).

The relationship is suddenly run by just one person, as opposed to thriving from an equal contribution of both partners.

All in all, they create a toxic environment that chokes out the life of love.

Until it stops breathing.

Conclusion

People fall out of love, that is a fact, whether we like it or not.

The sooner we start having a realistic view of love, and correct expectations of a relationship, the earlier we will find “Authentic Love.”

And believe me, eventually, this is what we all want and deserve.

So, the answer to the question from the beginning shouldn’t be “never,” but “it’s enough when there is no hope for Authentic Love.”

Please let me know about your experiences with falling out of love, and your thoughts in the comment section below.

Your friend,
Eddie Corbano

  • Lialandrum says:

    I was born and raised in San Francisco and when I was twenty I met a very nice boy at the city college.we became instant and vowed never to separate. My grandmother was prejudice and put an end to that relationship. Over two years I contacted him and he was still living at home. This Wes twenty five years later. He was still the same. We started seing each other but he had constant fears of leaving his house. I had a daughter in high school. We lived in different cities where he would ride the bus to see me every weekend. For two years we were the best I of freinds and had a simple but nice relationship. I had proposed a couple times that he moved here ang he only worked part time. After that something seemed to chane I don’t know what. His text messages became more distant. On the day he broke up with it was very hot In Santa Rosa and I said something and he told he didn’t feel a spark for me like he did twenty five years ago and he was trying to find it. I was very devastated he then asked me to wait while he saw a counselor. He couldn’t seem to make the call, after that he told me he wasnt coming on the weekend. I told him I didn’t want to be rejected any more. We had a ver nice relationship when we were young also. After that last conversation he closed the phone and refuses to talk. I thought it eas my second chance with him but it wasn’t. He has not called in three weeks . I was devastated because he was a good freind and a dood person and I don’t know what went wrong. Can anyone help

  • Marilyn A. says:

    Your articles have helped me tremendously. Thank you so much! My fiance/boyfriend & I recently broke up and although he wants to remain friends, I believe it’s best to just let go entirely. I would rather have a commitment over a friendship.

    • Hi Marilyn,

      good choice there. It is very hard to stay friends with someone you still have feelings for. Usually those that fell out of love already wish to stay friends.

      I did try staying friends with my ex who I still loved for quite some time after the break up. A very big mistake. It just prolonged my suffering and confusion and made things worse for me. The time alone after each break up is a must.

      Though I still do think of her even 3 years after but dont love her anymore I am still not sure whether I want to be friends with her again.

  • Melissa Oliver says:

    This post has really helped. It has been two weeks since my boyfriend dumped me and he has already started hooking up with someone else (this someone else has been a friend of his for 2 years). I was always suspicious of the relationship but everything was perfect in the beginning, until he started falling out of love. I never saw the signs but I wish I would’ve seen this earlier because I keep wondering could things have been different had I noticed him drifting away. This has been extremely hard for me because we have to see each other monday through friday and we share books, and we are in a group project together. By the way, I’m in college. But I just am in disbelief and I’m so happy that you wrote this post because it will help me in the future.

  • And Sarah…I respectfully disagree…that people can’t change. But, maybe I haven’t…maybe I just got back to being the guy she met, fell in love with, could trust and believe in! The MAN I really am inside and lost somewhere along the way:(

    • I just want to thank you all for all of your perspectives. I just found this site last night and it is wonderful. Such emotion and honesty and support.

  • Hi Kevin,

    didnt mean to offend you. Two months is not such a long time to get a new perspective. Not for you neither for her. I imagine that you might think that you cannot wait longer cuz things will go other ways you actuallly want. God knows I made a lot of mistakes during my last break up. It’s been almost 3 years after a 5 year long relationship and yet I still think of her often. So I am really not the right person to advice on approaching your ex. Though I will give you one advice. Do not try to qualify your new self to her. Thats a bit needy. Theres a lot of advice on the Internet on how to get back your ex. However I think in order to really get back together you must first move on and unlove her. There is no rule that once you unlove her that you two will never fall in love again. It might take longer than you wish though.

    I was in the same situation. I have changed as well. It took me longer than two months. I so wanted to get her back or at least my dream of her. It got me into this loop of wanting her back, still loving her, knowing that we will never get back together, trying to unlove her, trying to forget, loving her again and so on. It is a vicious circle. Not a good place to be in.

    I now know that I have change now only for her, but formyself and for someone new, who might appreciate my new self. Someone who will want to talk to and be with me. The thing with exes is that a lot of time must pass by for them to forgive and forget. Otherwise if you try too soon all they will do is to remember all the bad things – your old self.

    Also note that many times exes really do not know what they want. Many times they need to experience new things and new relationship so they can compare. Sometimes they will realize that the new is no better that the old.

    I am of the opinion that getting back together with an ex is never a good idea because there never really is a fresh start without all the old baggage.

    • Thanks for the reply…that was a lot better! and more helpful…and I apologize for my remark as it is simply an outward expression of the inner turmoil I am feeling. It has been longer than two months…we initially broke up for over three months during which time I received professional help. We were back together for a couple months and then she said she doesn’t feel the same way about “us”…she never says “you (meaning me)”…I interpret that as she doesn’t trust me, and I’ve given her no reason to. When we got back together we instantly started talking about marriage again which was obviously too fast for her. She has told me that during the original break up she was numb…and now she is mad! It’s horrible because I have changed and realized so much. I believe that she still loves me but doesn’t believe that we will be happy in the long run…but I KNOW we can. I’ve been in other relationships as has she (she was married for 10 years)…we both said we never felt this way before and I think we both meant it! (That hadn’t happened to me in the 41 years before I met her)I KNOW I meant it…I believe it’s worth saving…and I made all the mistakes…crying, pleading etc. I have now given her two weeks of no contact and am planning on at least 30 days…I’m just terrified that she’ll move on. I am trying to get and keep everything else in my life in order and I really don’t want to be in a relationship with someone who doesn’t truly want me. If I believed that to be the case I would try to move on instead of fix things…Thanks for the comment though…it did give me some insight.

  • People never really change. I dated this guy for six years who year after year told me he wanted to get married and live together. But it never did happen. He was really good to me and towards the end it really did seem like things were going to get better. I finally got him to go for a better job which he loved after working 6 years at a place he didn’t like. It was only a few hours away from where I lived so he made it a point to visit every week. But after about 3 months just like the article said he completely flipped and told me he wanted to see other girls and that he was bored of us, when just a week before the break up he was pointing out houses that were for sale. It has been 3 months and I’m still in complete shock and feel miserable everyday. It hasn’t gotten any better and honestly the thought of just dying is the only thing that brings peace to my mind. He was my best friend and one day he just turned around and left and hasn’t said a word to me since. I have come to realize that he probably never loved me and only used me as a distraction since he literally had nothing going for him.

  • Kevin,

    from what I read I am not sure whether you really are a changed man. Eitherway stop begging. The change you need to do is not for her or anyone else but you!

    Learn to be happy on your own. Stop looking for your happiness in someone else. The happiness rest inside of each of us. There is no way to find that in someone else but you. If you cannot find that inside of you all you are doing is trying to steal a bit of someone elses happiness. Thats a shitty thing to do.

    Some ships sale away forever. Deal with that.

    • I have alot of things i want to share with her! I’m not trying to steal her happiness. .. I’m trying to get her to see the difference. I woke up! If nobody ever needed anyone in life and everyone was completely happy alone then nobody would ever get married. I recognize my mistakes and would like another chance! And i know i may never get it. .. but was looking for advice on how to approach her… it’s hard to be happy with a gaping hole in your heart. .. And i know how to be happy alone. ..i wad fir awhile before i meet her. I’ve had manhunt feelings hurt before but this is completely different! Deal with that! g

  • One more thing too…when she actually broke up with me two months ago…I tried no contacting her. But it never lasted more than a week. I have begged her and pleaded to give us another chance. But she doesn’t know that I’ve learned all the things beyond my anger that led to me being a bad partner in life. Should I leave her alone or at least tell her those things in a letter? She did say that “if you really feel this way, the best thing you can do is let me recover”…”the texts and FB msgs are not helping”. I’m just afraid that if I leave the picture completely that she will move on to this person she is seeing permanently…never knowing the changes I’ve made! I am desperate for help…I don’t want to “trick” her into getting back together but I truly believe we would both be happy with the changes I’ve made! It’s what she really wanted when we were together!

  • Unfortunately, I KNOW my ex is the right person for me! I am the one that made all of the mistakes that led to the breakup. The final straw was I got drunk and was arrested for domestic violence (I did not hit/hurt her but broke items in our home).I wasn’t able to see her for four months due to the no contact order in place but then she wanted it lifted. We were together 5 years and I was not a good partner. We got back together for a couple months but then she actually broke up with me. She has said that she was numb for the time we were apart and that she is now “mad” at me…I also just found out that she is seeing someone now. We’ve been broken up for two months. I have made many changes in my life, don’t drink and am working on all of the areas that I know I let her down in. I still want her back! She is the best person I have ever known and up until the day I freaked out and broke things we were just as passionate and loving as day one! We were also like that during the reconnection. I know she doesn’t trust me, believe me and thinks that once I get comfortable, I will revert to my old self. I am a changed man and realize all the things I did wrong. How do I convince her that I am different and to give the “new me” (the person I REALLY am inside) another chance. She told me a week ago, that “she still loves me and always will, but that doesn’t meant we should be together. I realized that I feel different about “us” and it wasn’t coming back.” I understand that she doesn’t want things to be the same and they wouldn’t be…I know what I did wrong and I didn’t listen to her hints, pleas. Someone please help me…I love her completely, and want her in my life…she is the right person. I am 47 and have been in several relationships…this one was different and I have never felt this way about someone in my life! She said the same things to me…but now we don’t talk. This site is about moving on…but I know that’s not the right thing to do in this situation. People do get back together and have happy lives! I want that for us. If I can find a way to prove that I am the person she needs and that I saw what I did wrong, I believe it will work for us!!!

  • Hi Flo and all others navigating through these tough waters.Yes it’s very tough trying to make sense of this trying to find your way back out.Limbo land is the worst land, state to be in.
    I was doing fine after a year and a bit of no contact at all,no sightings until he came back in August to perhaps see if we could salvage some friendship see where it might go. I wanted everything to go back the way it was.As it turns out he just exploited my feelings for him for sex never intending to start anything again and that hurt more that the actual breakup.I felt used by him (and I was).I was blindsided and just wanted to believe that he had changed and finally wanted a real relationship.He told me he discovered Cialis and that it has a 4 day window.He also had shagged other people in his 4 day time soo now I have to go get tested.
    I am trying not to be bitter angry for I truly believed in him until now.
    I give it up to Karma to now to deal with him. I tell you this that although it looks like he’s moved on smoothly,so quickly effortlessly it might not be the case.You don’t know what’s going on beneath the surface.My guy got fired from his job after 33 years and I thought he was doing terrific without an us,not so.Hes lost face and is angry and perhaps that’s why he came back to trash me and hurt me.I honestly don’t know anymore but do understand that the focus should be solely on you now.Be the best you, you can be.Go out and buy something pretty,get a new haircut,join a yoga class.There are meetup.com groups all over the world we have one here it has 190 members.They go to dinner,dances,concerts,cross country,ski,hike,bike.Get out and meet some new people.Its not a dating site but a way to meet new friends.If I were closer to you I would say let’s go for coffee,shopping a few laughs.Listen to Eddie believe in this site for Eddy has been exactly where you and I are and he survived to find the best life.Believe better things are coming for you and me too.I play this game with myself I ask myself if you win the lotto today would you go back and get that person?NEVER EVER soo you are just hung up on what wasn’t and couldn’t be the future doesn’t hinge on people like that!
    hugs sending you good positives vibes,you will get through all things in time,
    Brenda

    • Hi Brenda!
      Thanks for your comment, I’m extremely sorry for what happened to you, your ex sounds like a real jerk.
      It’s so damn hard letting go. Tomorrow it’ll be a year since our first time out and the wound is still raw and open.
      I started dating again but just for the fun of it, nothing too serious, I can’t handle more than light and fun right now. Just the thought of putting myself in a vulnerable place makes me run into the opposite direction.
      But being able to be interested in someone else is a step forward I think. Even if I’m still struggling with the aftermath of my last relationship, I need to go out and have fun. I’m not so sure if it’s the best thing to do right now, but it helps.

  • I’ve had a miserable month. It’s been 10 months since our breakup and I still miss him terribly. He’s moved on, with a co-worker, which leaves me thinking whether he cheated on me or not.
    Is he happy? Does he really love her? I thought I’d be over this by now. But I’m still so angry, I’m still not able to let it go, I still miss him. It still hurts like crazy. I don’t know, probably all this resurfaced because it was his and my birthday recently and we ignored each other completely.
    There are days where I can ignore all this and move on with my life, and think I am happy. I’ve been keeping myself busy, but then, eventually the walls come tumbling down every single time.
    It still hurts so terribly. Is it going to stop someday? I wish I could stop remembering every single detail, it still hurts so much.
    And I know that calling or contacting him is stupid and desperate and so below me it’s not worth it. But today, all I’d really want is to undo the breakup. Or being able to finally let go. God, this in between is eating me up. I’m still in love and angry about it, at myself for not being able to move on, and at him for moving on so quickly, so smoothly. It’s been 9 months of no contact and live’s been easy for him, clearly. I’m so bitter and angry, some days I don’t recognize myself. This isn’t me at all. I want myself back and I’m not finding my way out…

  • I am in to my 7th month of break up after 10 years. This article is so true. I still get days where I wonder what he’s up to. I think its because he finished it by txt telling me how wonderful I was but he’d met some one else. I ave had no contact with him since that txt but still ave unanswered questions. My question is SLD I approach him for answers or just let it be.

    • Hi Deb

      It’s sad to hear your story. My opinion is I reckon let it be. If your ex has finished things off by text that is very lousy. It’s an act of cowardice really. Breakups should always be done face-to-face, and at worst over the phone. The fact he’d already met someone else when he texted you is an added reason to not search for answers. You deserve better than that. Everyone does. If you contact him you give away your power. You’ll find someone better out there that will treat you with respect.

  • You’re spot on JTW. Any rational person would not do a 180 flip without first having communicated all of their issues prior to ending the relationship.

    My last relationship was with a personality disordered person. Not being overly relationship experienced I failed to really reflect on the subtle red flags because I got caught up in being idealised like never before. It wasn’t until my ex made a big issue over me catching up with female friends (that wasn’t the first time there were inferences of potential cheating and I totally despise people who cheat) that it dawned on me that I was in a controlling and abusive relationship. I said I wanted a break and she came out with all of these issues never mentioned before, some of them imagined. When I tried to enforce some boundaries regarding trust and anger she decided to break things off. That part doesn’t hurt because I wanted a break from the relationship but it still has been very difficult to get over. More so the many instances of emotional abuse. It takes a heavy toll on your confidence and self-worth.

    You wonder if you were ever really loved at all, and from the reading I do, personality disordered people are not capable of real love, let alone genuine intimacy. It was a relationship that only lasted 2 months and thank god for that because I’ve being seeing a psychologist for the last 6 months, had suicidal thoughts for a few weeks early on, and have been on anti-depressants for most of the last 6 months.

    If you work out you’re in a relationship with a personality disordered person I think you’re best to just run as fast as you can. It’s really not worth the emotional toll it takes on you. I feel sorry for these people because they’ve usually been dealt a really bad hand by their parent(s) in their years as a child, but it doesn’t excuse them abusing their significant other.

    You’re right again JTW, if Eddie wrote about those kind of relationships he’d be writing for a long time. You live and learn.

  • I am in 22nd month of being alone after she left. I’ve called her many times and requested her to come back, but no result so far. I am the one who called, sent sms and tried, she never called me in 22 months. I miss my 3 sons, sometimes I cry for them alone at home.

    I think what Meg said is right that “a ‘dumper’ checks out of the relationship long before they actually say anything. That’s why it seems to come out of nowhere”. I now recall and relate a lot of warning signs that I didn’t really understood and therefore ignored them.

    Thanks Eddie for another good article.

    • UM… I’m in the same boat she left me 4 months ago & I miss my 2 kids can u please share your story whole story with me I need help…

  • Those quick “180 flips” some of you have experienced are the ending of relationships with disordered people. Unfortunately they are also some of the most difficult to get over. Mainly because you are placed on a pedestal one moment and the next you’re off and someone new is on it. If you look hard at the relationship and the person you were with, there were signs and red flags along the way.
    Had Eddie written about those relationships in this piece, it would have taken you days to read it. Perhaps he will in the future.

    • another challenge says:

      JTW, can you elaborate? What you have brought up about being with a disordered person is really interesting to me. I can’t find any meaning in the 180 and trying hard not to blame myself, even 4 months down the line. But the whole pedestal thing checks out: I was always put way up there which is why the crash was so hard. Have you had experience with this?

      • Hi another challenge. The 180 you’ve experienced could be what’s called splitting. Disordered people will idealize you to start with (place you on a pedestal), and tell you they’ve waited their whole life to meet someone like you. This is all done under the guise of hooking you in because deep down they know when you see their true colours you won’t like what you see.

        When you try and set boundaries on what you will and won’t accept the disordered person knows their cover is blown and you are the worst person on earth for not accepting their controlling and abusive behaviour. The hooking in part is done to keep you in the relationship thinking about how great things were at the start and wishing they would go back to that. I’ve experienced this first hand, and it took me a fair while after the relationship to fully comprehend what I’d been through. I feel sorry for people with disorders because they don’t see anything in shades of grey (realise people aren’t perfect), only in black or white. You will either be idealized or devalued and this can all happen in the same day.

        It still somewhat rankles me 7 months after the breakup but you learn to accept that you were in a relationship with a dysfunctional person and be on the lookout for red flags in future relationships.

        Another challenge; don’t blame yourself, this will destroy your self-esteem. Just know it wasn’t you. Rational, normal people don’t change that much in a relationship.

        • another challenge says:

          Hi LJN, thanks for the response.

          Ive started reading about personality disorders and the problem I am having is that only SOME of what is written describes her. She was in fact very caring, loving, kind and often also willing to negotiate. But then sometimes if I didnt agree with her way I would be labelled the worst person on earth, also she did throw tantrums often and it sometimes felt like she was trying to mould me into her perfect person (change this and that here and there) which infringed on some of my core tenets as my own person.

          She wasn’t abusive, but was sometimes quite controlling. And deep down, I think she loves herself, admires and respects herself and has a healthy ego. Sometimes it would be ‘too’ healthy if she was upset at me and say things that really made me mad, like “my ex bf’s wouldn’t have treated me this way”.

          In terms of what does check out as dysfunctional: Definitely putting me on a pedestal (I remember the first 6 mths of the relationship thinking how can someone love me so much when they dont really really know me yet?). She did all these little things above and beyond to show her love, almost every week it was something. Then when I didnt conform to her ideal, she would reference those things and say things like “I dont want to do that sort of thing for someone who doesnt love me back” … manipulation.

          The other thing that was dysfunctional was the way she left me. Not one single person I’ve spoken to has gone through this experience – someone saying they love you more than anything every day, then flipping out and never contacting again. It’s very very harsh.

          Anyway I guess these disorders are not black and white either, and there probably are many shades of gray, but to be honest I would find some solace in her being disordered ,even though that sounds bad. It just doesn’t 100% sit right though given she did so many loving and caring things throughout the relationship (such as taking care of me for almost 3 months when I came down with a potentially life threatening illness).. how does that check out??

          Thanks again

          • Hi another challenge,

            It’s hard to comment from what you’ve said, although I can say that a fairly rational person would not label you the worst person on earth for not agreeing with her. Nor would they throw tantrums often. If they’re trying to change you to the degree that it infringes on your core principles or beliefs that tells you that you were probably with the wrong person anyway.

            Here’s a great link to give you an insight on what abuse can constitute. http://shrink4men.wordpress.com/2009/01/23/when-love-hurts-the-emotionally-abused-man/comment-page-15/. If someone is trying to control you to a sufficient degree that can be abuse.

            Without being an expert, but having done an enormous amount of reading on disorders, I would guess that your ex may have been a very high functioning BPD/NPD. A rational person wouldn’t tell you they love you every day and then never contact you again. There would be some form of significant communication that things aren’t going so well and need to be worked out.

            You’re certainly right about there being shades of grey with disorders. Some are high functioning, and the signs of the disorder would be quite subtle and covert. With the lower functioning, you would be able to tell very early on that things are not right. I can understand how you would find solace in your ex being disordered given how you were treated. When you talk about her caring for you for almost 3 months was there any expectation that you would return the favour, or that you owed her massively? Disordered people will generally not do anything for anyone else unless it comes at a cost to you.

          • Hi LJN76 and another challenge,

            I am so glad I came across your comments!

            I was seeking for answers how my extremely sweet and loving boyfriend decide to call it off on the day of my birthday and how he could go from you are the woman of my dreams to I don’t feel the same anymore overnight. He has gone all out of his way and treat me like a princess but he has extreme jealousy and was controlling. It does feels like he was keeping tabs of all his contribution to the relationship and said why did I never meet him halfway.

            I have just done a whole heap of readings on BPD after coming across your comments and it does seem like my ex boyfriend is diagnosed with this too. I guess now it all makes sense. Although he was no where near abusive, but he was very controlling and manipulative.

            It does give me a whole lot of clarity and now I am just trying to work out how to help him (whether he is aware of this disorder or not!)

          • The one eighty happened to me too. I loved a man that I loved many years ago and reconnected with him, I thought he was my second chance at love. I had a very hard life and he knew it. We lived in two different counties and he rode the bus every weekend to see me. After two years of what I called the perfect relationship I asked him to move with me. Things went downhill from there. He started acting strange and distant toward me. After that he told me that he didn’t feel like he loved me like he did twenty five years ago. I guess he basically meant he was leaving. I was devastated. It got worse from there he promised to see a counselor and became too scared to go. He told me he idealized me in his mind and I was just a regular person. I was his first and last girlfriend. I told hi I did not want to be rejected anymore and he stopped speaking to me. It has been one month. My daughter who’s in college thanked him for her birthday present and he texted her.i cried for one month. I am a very nice person and could not fathom why this happened with someone who I felt was perfect. I’m recovering slowly and all of you will too. It’s difficult to have no contact when someone isn’t contacting you. I am not a young girl and many years ago almost thirty my grandmother broke up the relationship because he was a different nationality than me. I miss him and words cannot express how he broke my heart but for all keep your chins up it will get better. I promise

        • Hi

          I’m just reading this article out of interest and have come across your comments.

          I was in this exact relationship about 12 months ago, and you have just explained it perfectly. Like you it took me a while to comprehend what I had been through, and it had actually had become damaging to my peace of mind.

          I was made to believe I was ‘amazing’, this was obviously in the first few months, when quite honestly you are still getting to know each other and you don’t care as much. When it started to become serious, and I set boundaries I was made to feel like I was ‘crazy’, and all I wanted was to go back to the beginning when we had fun.

          Thank you so much for this, you have really given me clarity.

          • Happy to help Mel. If you’ve been through anything like what I have, which it sounds like you have it can really stuff you around mentally. I’ve needed 7 months of work with a psychologist and doing an immense amount of reading to put it all together but it has been worth it.

            You’re spot on about still getting to know each other in the first few months. Being placed on a pedestal so early on can be a bit hard to comprehend. It’s a big red flag. Good on you for enforcing boundaries. If you set reasonable boundaries which most rational people do, you soon work out whether someone might be right for you by the way they react!

            I’ve been helped by other people on here and am glad to have given you clarity.

        • LJN76 I really can not tell you how much that comment has just helped me. It’s exactly what I have been through over the last 14 months. It crushed me. I have been beating myself up but your post have helped.

          • Thanks for the kind words DLG. I’m glad I’ve helped. I’m sorry to hear you’ve been through the same thing for that period of time. Don’t beat yourself up over it. You did your best. Time heals all wounds but focusing on doing things that make you happy will help you even more to get through this. I wish you all the best.

      • I think he is referring to what it is like to be broken up with by someone who has a personality disorder or mental illness. I am dating a narcissist now and he has threatened violence against me and/or my family if I leave him. He also shows signs of antisocial personality and paranoid personality disosorder. Living with him has been and still is a nightmare. I am currently trying ‘the gray rock method’ and I hope it makes him want to discard me.

    • JTW, the 180 flip and being put on the pedestal makes it very hard to get over a breakup.

      My gf recently broke up with me, we were together for almost 4 years. Before this, neither us were in a relationship for this long.

      When we first met, she was extremely into me, she was very aggressive in getting to know me, and asked a mutual friend to introduce us, she later told me when she shook my hand she knew “she was in trouble” (even though she doesn’t know anything about me at that point). After that for 2 years, she put me on this pedestal, and think our relationship was the best, that we were the best couple, and that she never gets sick of me. She really doted on me. As for me, i was hesitant to date her at first, but she hooked me in.

      Two years was a long time, so I thought she really was into me, and not just a fluke. Slowly I found out that she has many issues, she couldn’t sleep unless she takes Xanax every night, which is a very addictive sedative, she told me it was subscribed to her for anxiety. This was later changed to Trazodone, and then Ambien. Essentially the doctor refused to keep her on Xanax.

      Soon after the two years, we began having more arguments, and I can feel she no longer treats me the same, eventually I confronted her and she told me the usual “i love you, but I’m not in love with you”. We took 2 weeks off, and slowly piece back the relationship, I told her i would change (i know…).

      I thought things were getting better, we were back to having sex, but she always seemed hesitant, and says i’m not romantic enough and too pushy. Then after the third year, she revealed to me she’s bulimic and have body image problem, and has been for many years. She started seeing a nutritionist and therapist, and began taking Prozac, which is an anti-depression medication, its most common side effect is low libido and sexual dysfunction. Her mother also has end stage kidney failure, and only has 4 months to live. Throughout all this I was very supportive of her and her family, I even found her mother a nephrologist and helped her get treatment.

      However, I can feel certain warning signs start to crop up in our relationship. She seems to be emotionally numb, and don’t laugh as much, she no longer wear the jewelry i bought her, she no longer cleans up her apartment before I come over, and on the phone she’s not her usually bubbly self, etc, etc.

      Then suddenly last week, I asked her about all this, and she says she doesn’t feel anything for me, and wants us to see other people (even though just 4 days ago, we had intercourse, and she told me she loves me). It was too sudden, I was heartbroken, as I invested so much into her. Now she has made her future facebook posts invisible to me, even though we are still “friends” on facebook, I assume she might be seeing other people. We are currently in No Contact period.

      I don’t know if this is her disorder, or it was because i’m a bad guy. I’m a relatively shy person who works very hard, I’m a half year away from finishing Medical School; I work a lot, and don’t have many friends, and i think toward the end of our relationship, I was becoming more needy towards her.

      Right now it just hurts so bad, and I don’t feel like I have anyone in my life. And she seems to have lost feelings for me a year ago, and never recovered, then strung me along for another year. I feel betrayed and hurt, and can’t move on.

  • Yikes such a strong article.Thanks Eddie for this even if we don’t really want to hear it.Part of me feels like it’s just however pouring salt in the wound that’s already tough to scab over.
    I think when we embark on a relationships, there really isn’t any guarantee that the other person in totally on board.Soo do we not go down that road with them?do we always look for,constantly check for signs something isn’t right?or do we just go forward with hope in our hearts that this could really go someplace?and have some kind of trust?
    I feel awful I do I want to believe in true love “authentic love” but at the same time I feel jaded and hurt and depressed about the whole relationship thing.Should I just stay alone now?They say time heals all and I try to keep busy, take trips away to tropical fun places hoping for time to hurry me along to a better place.I just don’t know anymore guess I am in a blue funk!
    This will pass but it just sucks big time and where do you go to try to meet anyone?tired of those dating sites,tired of people misrepresenting themselves who have been married multiple times with no stickability.
    Cheers all,keep the faith as I will try to just having a pity party tonight lol
    Brenda

  • another challenge says:

    “Secondly, it really doesn’t happen over night. It’s a process that needs time.”

    How much time is what shocked me. She literally did a 180 in 2 weeks. Before that we were planning on marriage and family. Then we had a massive fight that we could just not resolve, followed by 2 weeks of ‘alone time’ to figure out how to resolve our ends of the argument on our own. At the end of those 2 weeks, I got the ‘I don’t love you anymore’ treatment, and haven’t heard from her for 4 months since then. We were together for 2.5 years, living together for 1 and during that time every day she told me she loved me, convincing me we were meant to be together and that she was the one.

    If that doesn’t shake your faith in love, I dont know what does.

    • I was in the same situation as you. We were together for 4.5 years. He never brought it up…I eventually had to ask him if he wanted to be in a relationship and if he loved me. That’s when he told me he didn’t love me and had been feeling that way for over a year. Every single day up until the day I asked him, he told me he loved me and reaffirmed his love. Now that is a blow to the heart.

      At that time, I found this website and it got me through a very tough time in my life and helped a lot. I realized I deserved someone who loved me and was willing to put effort into our relationship. My faith in love had seriously been shaken to the core. I couldn’t trust anyone because I had believed a lie for over a year.

      That was 5 years ago. 4 years ago I met a man who restored my faith in love and made me believe in love again. Our relationship is not perfect, we have our ups and downs, but the difference is we work things out together. We are a team and fight for each other.

      I think it is very true that the “dumper” checks out of the relationship long before they actually say anything. That’s why it seems to come out of nowhere. I believe the “dumper” says I love you etc. simply out of habit and doesn’t know how to get out of the situation.

      I know things are hard right now, but things do get better. I know it is very easy to say, but stay strong and follow the advice on this site…it is great information.

      • another challenge says:

        Thanks for the kind words meg. I am working on being a better person. Nothing else to do in the meantime while the pain remains.. 🙂

  • A brilliant read that makes sense when I stand back objectively, devoid of emotional attachment to her for a moment and let it sink in. My experience was with a woman that I dated several times over 20 years ago and we lost touch until we connected online 2 yrs. ago, and both of us were hungry for the connectedness of what we believed to be love, ie. the love letters flowed over our 2,000 mile distance from one another for 3 mos., with daily conversations and plans for the future together. All this after having had a date 20 yrs. earlier to see an afternoon matinee of the Broadway Musical, Cats, and seeing her once more without sex arriving in the moment…

    She came to me in the mtns. of Colorado, and I came back with her to Florida, and it lasted 10 months, with all of the above symptoms appearing to one degree or another. And yes, she moved on within months with someone new, and I held on, obsessing over the loss, and esp. imagining her in another man’s arms now. She in fact, never responded to my calls during the course of our first 8 mos. apart, and finally via email told me not to call, email or contact her again, and naturally I insisted on knowing why and what happened following our “temporary” separation I thought…and her answer was have him call me and tell me that he was 13 yrs. younger than her, and that the promise ring that I gave her meant “nothing” to her now…Talk about a bitter pill…I’ve tried to drink through the emotional pain, work out to feel temporarily better, though father time has worked best, and I still wonder “why is it that a woman can give her heart away so easily when a man can suffer terminally holding on to something that once was, and no longer is”? A mystery to me even still… Thanks for the wake up Eddie…I’m going home…

    • Sorry to hear this Tim. I guess we will never understand women completely, anymore than they will understand us. I feel your pain, I truly do. I wish there was a switch sometimes that we could just flip and not feel anymore, but I guess that’s what makes us human.

  • Amazing. So true, so wise as usual. Thank you very much. When it comes to long-distance relatonships I guess it’s a mix of more than just one option. I love my ex and we are both still single but no talking of course, nor living in the same country. It’s been a year and a half since we broke up. He just unfriended me on FB less than two months ago so that’s how I found you, I didn’t think that was going to hurt after all but it did. I’m healing and you have been of tremendous help! I do believe this is true. It’s important..the watering the plant, not being needy, having your own life, etc but..it’s complicated to say exactly what will work and what not or whether if that’s even possible. It’s also a matter of timing and luck and we will never know but it’s good to just be ready and improve ourselves for whatever the future might bring 🙂

    • Hey gressia,

      I know how it felt. I was left almost 5 months. Stick to this site and no contact rules. Long relationship is hard. I also was in the same situation as you and I was keeping going to his FB although he unfriended me just to.., you know seeing him there and missing him even more. But it will get better just stick to the rule. Break it is the worst possible idea. As I am now broke my 4 and a half month record accidentally. I do feel a lot better and hopefully will get on a date soon.

      Cheers!!

  • One of the truest and poignant posts ever written. It actually helped me alot. I am two months from being “dumped” and for the most part I am getting through it. I have the odd day though where I really miss my ex girlfriend and obsess over why we broke up. We have to share a house for the immediate future which makes things very hard sometimes. She ‘seems’ over me and is dating a new guy. I have been on dates but they purely fill a gap and have gone nowhere, mostly out of my choice. I am definitely not ready to be in another relationship. But this post has really, really helped. It has snapped me into making a few realizations of truths that perhaps I wasn’t ready to accept. She was definitely on the road to being over me before she ended the relationship and was in a new one within two weeks. I don’t think it is working out how she’d like but it has still given her an emotional crutch and the sense of validation she requires to boost her self esteem. I actually disagree with the whole rebound thing as I don’t think you really get over the previous person, you just replace them. SO in conclusion, in my eyes, I am perhaps further down the road of recovery than she is. Thanks for the great post.

  • >